Halloween was a day Jeff would never forget. He found out his girlfriend was pregnant. One prank found him trapped under a chicken coop; another prank ended in gunfire; and another prank turned into a rolling inferno which burnt part of the nearby woods. He should have known a visit to Witch’s Cave would be a bad idea, but he and his friends couldn’t resist getting the desires of their hearts.
In episode two, Jeff deals with the reality of becoming an adult and taking care of his pregnant girlfriend. When death comes to someone connected to the group, Jeff begins to wonder if perhaps they had unwittingly invoked a sinister power, but can he convince others to help him stop this power before death strikes others in their small community?